Bethlehem Evangelical Lutheran School began in a small log structure in 1879. This building also served as the church.  (see photo right)

in 1902, a schoolhouse was built during Pastor William Meyer's pastorate. In the early times all instruction was given in german. Then in 1914, some english Confirmation instruction was given "when necessary." During this time and up until 1920, the resident pastor taught school. After that, the congregation endeavored to engage vicars or supply teachers.

In 1920, S. H. Beckman, who later became a pastor, was the first of these ministerial students to teach at Bethlehem. 

In 1943, the school was moved from the northwest corner of the cemetery to across the road on the two acres that the church had purchased. A basement was added at that time as well. In 1951, water was piped to the school from the parsonage making a welcome addition to the comfort of the students. Also in 1951, Bethlehem's first "called" teacher, Mr. Raymond Flesch, arrived from the school at River Forest. In June 1961, Mr. Flesch accepted a call to Wilton Junction, Iowa. This teaching position was filled in the fall of 1961 by Mr. Ronald Koehler of Freemont, Wisconsin.

The 85th Anniversary of the Day School was commemorated in 1964. 

Mr. James Hanson of Redwood City, California arrived in September 1964 and would accept a call just three years later in September 1967 to Hollywood Township in New Germany, Minnesota.  

In 1967, Mr. Darwin Scauer of Green Isle, Minnesota was the fourth and last called teacher.

The school was remodeled in 1969. 

Sadly, the school closed its doors permanently on May 31, 1971.