320.963.3592
7809 County Road 35 W
Middleville Township
Annandale, Minnesota
1878 - 1913
The first services were held in a little red school house which was located near the Emil Hoffman farm. Pastor Karl Mende, age 23, came from Albany, Minnesota in 1876 to conduct services in the school house in Albion Township once a month. The confirmation classes were held at St. James in Howard Lake. Pastor Mende married Augusta Caroline Emilie Uecker, a sister to Otto and Fred Uecker, on July 10th, 1879.
​
Having gathered a number of people to worship, Bethlehem Evangelical Lutheran Church was organized on the 10th of February in 1878 by Pastor Mende.
However, differences in doctrine soon caused dissension yet, a few remained faithful to their Pastor. These 14 were the charter members of Bethlehem Evangelical Lutheran Church: Ludwig Grothmann, Friedrich Uecker, Otto Uecker, J. Kamman, William Oletzke, Friedrich Adam, John Schmidt, Johann Marohn, Adam Koepke, Andreas Koepke, Christian Adam, Carl Pomerenke, Carl Mathan and Andreas Bobrowske. Many of their families/relatives remain in the church today - a tribute to the church's ability to create a loving, caring, and long-lasting family.
​
The first elders and trustees were Ludwig Grothmann, Friedrich Uecker, and John Marohn.
​
In 1879, Pastor Mende accepted a call to Illinois.
Pastor Mende passed away December 16, 1906 at the age of 53. His wife, Augusta, passed away two days later at the age of 49.
Pastor Karl J. Mende and Mrs. Mende
The Bethlehem parish united with the congregation in Howard Lake to call Pastor F. Kolbe. Upon Pastor Kolbe's arrival in 1879, the congregation resolved to build it's first church, a log structure measuring twenty by thirty feet. It was built of hewn logs. A small table covered with a plain black cloth stood in the sanctuary. There was also a chair for the pastor to sit on. When the church was well attended, the people sat on a small platform right around the Pastor.
Pastor F. Kolbe
In a congregational meeting on January 14, 1883, a resolution was passed that in each service the "klingelbeutel" was to be passed around. A klingelbeutel is a cloth bag attached to a long handle into which voluntary money donations are collected during the service. Sometimes a little bell is fastened to the bag; this is the reason for it's German name. When it is used nowadays, the 'klingelbeutel' is passed through the rows in the church during the singing of a hymn. In this way the offertory is collected.
​
The first benches were put into the church in 1886. They were made of basswood boards and basswood blocks. Hitching posts were also put up for the horses and other improvements were made to the church property.
​
Pastor Kolbe began teaching school in 1887 between Easter and Pentecost and six long benches had been made for the children to sit on. Friedrich Adam boarded Pastor Kolbe and his horse for $3.00 a week. This included room and meals for him and his horse.
Although Pastor Kolbe had been preaching services and teaching school at Bethlehem for 11 years, he was not a full time pastor. On January 3rd, 1890, the congregation decided to call their first resident pastor, Rev. Ernst J. Stahlke of Lodge Pole, Nebraska. He accepted the call and was ordained in the fall of 1890. He stayed at the home of Otto Uecker. Pastor Stahlke's tenure of office was quite short. After less than one year of service, illness forced him to resign and shortly after that, he passed away at the age of 25 and was laid to rest at Trinity Lutheran Cemetery in Waconia, MN.
​
On October 12, 1890 a meeting was called to decide on the purchase of 1/2 acre of land for $25.00 and to build a new parsonage. It was decided to do so and Otto Uecker, William Oletzke and Chas. Mistelske were assigned the building committee. The dimensions of the house were 18 x 26 x 14 feet high. The kitchen was 18' x 26'. The building was made of brick veneer.
​
Little is known about our first resident Pastor except what was provided by his brother, Mr. Otto Louis Stahlke, for our Diamond Jubilee celebration book. At that time, Otto Stahlke, a retired parochial teacher, was residing in Glencoe, Minnesota. He tells us this of his brother, "Rev. Ernst Jr. Stahlke was born September 27, 1865 near Waconia, Minnesota. After his graduation from seminary in Springfield, Illinois in 1888, he was assigned to a missionary field in western Nebraska, which was just opened for settlement shortly before. He served eight stations located a distance of about 100 miles along the Union Pacific railroad."
In July 1891, Reverend John S. Hertrich (47 years old), was called. During Pastor Hertrich's pastorate, the congregation experienced a remarkable growth. The congregation resolved to erect a new church. The building committee met with a company in St. Paul, Minnesota. It was decided that the building would be 34 x 56 and be made of bricks. The congregation agreed to the price of $2,500. Pastor Hertrich had the daunting task of collecting the money from individual members of the congregation. After collecting most of the money needed, the building committee was informed from the St. Paul architect that the actual cost to build the church would be $3,000, not the $2,500 originally quoted. Due to the hard times of 1893, this resolution to build was not carried out. The money collected was returned to the donors by Pastor Hertrich.
In 1896, Pastor John S. Hertrich accepted a call to Plato, Minnesota.
​
Pastor Hertrich passed away in November of 1934 at the age of 90.
In 1896 Pastor Klingbeil was called and installed later in the fall of that year. In 1899, it was again resolved to erect a new church. This new resolution was for a church smaller than the one planned in 1892 and it was to be made of wood instead of bricks. It was noted that the church would cost $3,000 to build, the same as it would have a few year earlier. The resolution passed, the building committee was formed, and the money was collected. The current church was built. Members of the building committee were William Oletzke, Ed Vogel, John Marohn, Otto Uecker and Fred Adam.
Pastor J. S. Hertrich
Pastor and Mrs. Meyer
Mrs. Caroline Uecker donated the bell which still serves the congregation today. Little is known about the instillation of the bell. The bell rang early on Sunday mornings for those in hearing distance to know church was going to start shortly. It was pulled by the rope that is still in use today.
​
On February 26, 1901 Pastor Klingbeil left the congregation.
​
On April 28, 1901 Pastor William Meyer of Mellard, South Dakota was called. During his pastorate at the school house was built.
In June 1902 the pipe organ was purchased and other various improvements were made. Herman Benecke was the organist for thirty years. During Pastor Meyer's pastorate, the congregation again experienced another remarkable growth. On August 29, 1909 Pastor Meyer was released to Afton, Minnesota.
Pastor Meyer, at the age of 80 years old, would return again to attend and celebrate Bethlehem's 75th Anniversary.
​
In 1909, Pastor Ferdinand Vahl was called from North Branch, Minnesota. He passed away just four years later on March 21, 1913 at the age of 52. Pastor Vahl is the first of two pastors buried in our cemetery.
​
Above is a picture of the altar and organ shortly after the organ was purchased and installed.
(Notice the German writing above the sanctuary arch, the white alter & pulpit, and the light fixture hanging from the ceiling)
